I had been hoping that Istanbul would be a new kind of revelation for me. Often described as the one place in the world where East truly meets West -- the city is literally cut in half by the Bosphorus river, the left bank being Europe and the right bank Asia. Turkey is squeezed between Europe and the Middle East, with 1000 miles of it's border shared among Iran, Iraq, & Syria. But it is still a center of moderate Islam and a living, breathing demonstration that a large majority Islamic community can live in a modern, democratic state. However, it's far from perfect.
Several times over the past year, hundreds of thousands of people have gathered in the streets of Turkey to protest the democratically-elected, Islamic-leaning government for fear of small concessions to the Muslims. Their strongest objection was to allow women to wear head scarves in university, which seems me is a basic right and an important step to granting equality to women. There seems to be extraordinary fear that the fundamentalists are plotting to take over the country and any small freedom of religion within the government run institutions might 'start the ball rolling.' In fact, the state's leading prosecutor brought the entire ruling party to the Supreme Court in an attempt to prove this. Imagine Elliot Spitzer drooling over that prize.
Given the current secularism after a long time of Islamic rule, the court thankfully ruled that the evidence wasn't sufficient, and the progressive Muslim AKP party that has made huge strides for Turkey will remain. It's a democracy and so they'll need to prove they mean what they say. If they people want them out, it should be in the voting booth, not in the courts.
All of this fascinating modern history (for me at least) combined with Turkey's controversial attempts to join the EU (starting in 1987 and continuing for at least another 10 years from now) made me feel that Istanbul was a key stop on my journey.
What better way to enter the Middle East than through a country fighting within itself to prove that the West and Islam can live together in peace?
Too Much Politics
My expectations must have been too high. While I toured around the city, I looked on every street corner, in every shop for a sense of the culture that could make all this happen. Nothing I found offered me the answer. The food was a nice collection of mezes (like Middle Eastern tapas), but seemed to be like what I found anywhere else in the area. The mosques were magnificent...
...but a brief entry, look, and exit left me feeling like I was being tolerated rather than welcomed. The Topkapi Palace, with it's tales of concubines and eunuchs serving spoiled kings, was dry and only made me further increase my appreciation for the wonder of Versailles.
This isn't to say I didn't enjoy Istanbul. I met a few fantastic people, one of whom I joined for a boat trip up the Bosphorus all the way to the Black sea.
I also wandered through the markets and ate Turkish Delights.
But I think I left feeling that everything was an East/West compromise. Like Greece meets Egypt, but without any of the charm of either place. Either I'd been travelling for too long already, or that's what happens under such trying conditions -- no one side makes too much of a mark.
Shortly after I left Turkey, one side possibly affiliated with al-Qaeda tried hard to make its mark, setting off two massive bombs just outside the city. Yet another reminder that the argument is not settled.
Tennessee. Really?
I suppose the thing I found most interesting was the number of people I met who were taking 3-4 week trips only within Turkey. Surely my one week wasn't enough, but I didn't expect to find families from Tennessee taking their summer vacation. I learned they were looking for some of the same things as me - an exposure to an Islamic country that had reconciled many of its differences. This, combined with world-class historical sights like Ephesus makes for quite a holiday. A chance for American kids to see first hand what their neighbors were fighting for. I don't know if they found it - one sullen 14-year old told me that after this trip he never wanted to travel with his family again - but it's certainly an admirable goal.
A 19th century Japanese dish on display at the Topkapi Palace